Boards with custom graphics?

Drew · #1

I don't play it, but I've always admired fancy Crokinole boards. You can see some stunning examples in this gallery:

http://boardgamegeek.com/images/boardga ... ter=&B1=Go

So that lead me to wonder if anyone has customized Go boards? I can't recall ever seeing one. It occurred to me that a background graphic might visually distract from focusing on the game. After all, Go is slightly more mentally demanding than Crokinole!

Regardless, just for fun, I threw this together in Powerpoint in about 30 seconds. The choice of motif is up to the creator. Thoughts?

DrStraw · #2

I think I will pass on this one.

tentano · #3

This kind of decoration isn't particularly sought-after.

Most of admiration goes out to wooden boards, with the kaya wood ones being most highly priced.

There's a lot that COULD be done, but the simple truth is that most players don't want it. Even highly decorative tables made in the past for high-ranking nobility tend to leave the playing area blank except for the grid.

I think it's because go is such a visual game, any decoration of the playing field would serve as an annoying distraction.

Interestingly, there's a niche market for stones made of materials like amethyst, onyx, jade or lapis lazuli. They're pretty uncommon, though, and I've never actually played with anything other than plastic (ew), glass, or the traditional slate and shell.

Elom · #4

Might be slightly off topic, so hidden:

EdLee · #5

Annoying.

xed_over · #6

I'm afraid your talking with mostly extreme traditionalist. They will never like it.

I like it. I think its ok.

Bantari · #7

xed_over wrote:

I'm afraid your talking with mostly extreme traditionalist. They will never like it.

I like it. I think its ok.

Its not about being a traditionalist. Images like that, right smack on the surface of the board, just detract from the actual position, and take away from the beauty of the game itself.

However, nice graphics next to the board is another thing. Either as wooden carving for real boards or as background for on-line gaming.

Example: Panda and the late Kaya put some effort into beautifying the screen graphics for board display to create a beautiful, yet pleasantly subdued, feel. I like that.

But when you start putting annoying images on the board itself, its so... arcade.

Tim C Koppang · #8

Elom wrote:

When printing out 9x9 boards on paper, I always thought that if they're going to be used to introduce young children to baduk, that a background which doesn't argue with the lines and stones, is a plus. Something as simple as allowing toddlers to choose what colour board they want to use or (better!) what colour or design of stone they want to use, may increase the attention span ever so slightly.

Not a bad idea if it helps bring children to the game. The obvious counterpoint would be that children all over the world already get into the game as is. But that's not to say there isn't room for some whimsical improvements. I'm reminded of the Go-like game, Snorkels, which attempts to teach the basics of Go while using an underwater theme. Here's a close-up of the pieces.

CnP · #9

I've seen (online) some 9x9 boards with the playing surface decorated with Hikaru no Go characters. I can't find an example now though of course.

oren · **#10**

CnP wrote:

I've seen (online) some 9x9 boards with the playing surface decorated with Hikaru no Go characters. I can't find an example now though of course.

A couple of them here..

http://www.amazon.co.jp/%E3%83%91%E3%83 ... E%E7%A2%81

http://www.amazon.co.jp/%E3%83%91%E3%83 ... E%E7%A2%81

Boards with custom graphics?

Who is online