darthmage wrote:
Just re-played the game on my board, paying attention to some of the variations you suggested. It was very helpful
A related question : For understanding shape in a way useful for games, are Tsumego problems the best way ? Or already at my level should I slowly pick up a set of good/bad shapes from a combination of books, lectures and articles (eg: I have heard from our forums here that "Shape Up !" is a classic ?)
There is shape to tsumego, but it is special. Its aim is to make or break eyes in a small space. Shape is about local efficiency. Outside of tsumego, that can involve making or breaking eyes, but there are other aims. Shortage of liberties can be an important factor, tsumego or not.
I first got a book about shape when I was around 3 kyu. It made a big difference in my game.

I do not know about when is the best time to study shape. My guess is that it is not too early, if you can understand the material.

Certainly it is not too soon to look for shortage of liberties. Even 10 kyu players make many mistakes by not paying attention to it.

There is a popular misconception about shape, that some shapes are good in themselves, without regard for the opponent's stones. If you just went around making such shapes while your opponent took big points elsewhere, you would lose. Certainly you can make bad shape all by yourself, but good shape depends upon where the opponent's stones are, what they threaten, what your stones threaten.
The study of shape goes hand in hand with the study of tesuji. Often good shape prevents an opponent's tesuji, sometimes it threatens your own tesuji, or is tesuji itself.
Here is a rule of thumb that you can apply at your level. If one player or another has two more stones (or more) than the opponent in a local area, that
may indicate inefficiency. As the game goes on, such situations are unavoidable, but the earlier in the game that it occurs, the more likely that the side with more stones is inefficient.
So if you already have one more stone in a local region than your opponent and you are thinking of playing another stone there, ask yourself whether you need to make that play now or whether there are bigger or better plays somewhere else. (OC, that rule of thumb does not apply when the opponent makes an invasion, for instance, because you start out with more stones than the opponent.

)