What is silly about expecting people to have manners?

_________________
Patience, grasshopper.

Nothing. But its all in the definition... isn't it?

For example:
I don't think saying "tx" instead of "thank you" is bad manners. It does not offend me.
However - forcing me to behave in a certain way just to satisfy your definition of "manners" - this is rude.

But I am probably weird, so peace out.

_________________
- Bantari
______________________________________________
WARNING: This post might contain Opinions!!

The KGS handle "mimosa" is still available, if it helps.

I'm not forcing anybody to do anything, so I hope you don't consider me rude for stating how a specific behavior makes me feel. One of the functions of (good) manners is to smooth social interactions. A tense game in which tempers can flare is a good example of a situation in which manners can have an influence. You can quibble all you want about what exactly constitutes good or bad manners, but wordlessly leaving a game doesn't leave that much room for interpretation. It is an absence of any communication, which also includes an absence of the desire to express any good will. If your toothache doesn't prevent you from playing a game, it certainly shouldn't prevent you from typing. As to whether one types "thanks for the game," "thanks" or "tx," they all indicate the same sentiment, and uttering this sentiment is the norm, in other words, the defacto standard on western go servers for good manners. It is what people do to smooth the social interaction. I understand the desire to rebel against social norms in general as no one wants to be herded like sheep, but there ought to be a good reason for not adhering to the norm in this specific case, as it has the consequences of making the social interaction for some people such as myself more difficult.

_________________
Patience, grasshopper.

There is no force involved. I am merely exercising my right not to continue with any further games. If someone chooses to smoke in my presence then I will avoid them in the future. That is not forcing them to stop smoking. But if they want to continue to interact with me then they have the option to stop.

_________________
Still officially AGA 5d but I play so irregularly these days that I am probably only 3d or 4d over the board (but hopefully still 5d in terms of knowledge, theory and the ability to contribute).

I used to type Hello, have a good game,
then I went to hi gg,
then I went to gg,
then I went to G,
then I decided it was better to keep quiet in case what I had written was used in evidence against me.

_________________
North Lecale

I usually wish my opponent an enjoyable game and then thank them at the end. Sometimes we get into a self-review if there's interest, otherwise I just do it myself.

I can't figure out how to chat on Tygem though, using the iOS client. As far as I can tell there's no way to do it, so I probably across as rude there.

full conversation? I can't do it.
I might enjoy it, sure, but I'm playing a game and trying to concentrate on finding my next moves.
Its probably the part I enjoy the most about in-person over-the-board games, but still find it distracting (and I feel guilty for distracting my opponent when I do)

If someone doesn't chat at all, it's worth giving them the benefit of the doubt. Maybe they don't speak even rudimentary English. Maybe they didn't notice the chat window. Heck, maybe they're banned from chatting. There's no reason to assume they intended to be rude.

On the other hand, if they follow up a victory with "LOL EZ," all bets are off.

You are feel free to avoid whomever you like, for whatever reasons, no hard feelings. I do it all the time, to all kinds of people - even on this forum.

The problem I have is with calling people "jerks" - just because they do something you find less than fully pleasing.
If you dislike smoking - avoid smokers, no problem. But this does not mean all smokers are "jerks".
If you dislike people saying "gg" - avoid them as well. But this does not mean they are all "jerks".
Yet this is specifically what the OP stipulated, and the major point of my contention.

When you talk about your experience - as I did - and order it from more pleasurable to less pleasurable - this is your prerogative, and perfectly natural.
However - when you start calling people "jerks" just because they don't fully please you - then you are in danger of moving into this category yourself, in my eyes.

I hope this makes it more clear.

----------
PS>
Also, when you think about it a little more in this light - you will realize that there is some measure of social force exerted in this scenarion - much more so than if you simply avoided me. I don't mind being avoided, but I don't necessarily want to be though of as "jerk" and you possibly spreading a word that I am a "jerk", telling all your friends. So, in principle, you blackmail me into going out of my way to please you - or else you think or say bad things about my character.

There are things I might do to warrant you doing just that!
But saying "gg" instead of "Have a nice game, sire, pretty please" - this is not one of those things. Imho.

_________________
- Bantari
______________________________________________
WARNING: This post might contain Opinions!!

I addressed a little the issue of "forcing" in the post to Dr.Straw. Let me know if you need more explanation.

As for how you feel - this is normal, and you are certainly feel however you like, and express it too.
If that was all - I would have no problems. I actually share your feelings, mostly.

But then you start calling people "jerks" - and that changes the dialogue.


I understand your point, but I simply disagree with you in the evaluation.
I think that saying "tx" makes for every bit as "smooth" interaction (or even smoother, although maybe less pleasurable for both uf us) as saying "Thank you for good game, sir, Have a nice day."

The same goes for just leaving. Why do you think you deserve any "thanks" for losing a game? I mean - it would be nice to get a "thank you" - I fully agree - but I don't think its a crime to skip it. Maybe the other guy felt offended because he felt you did not offer him a good enough game, you did not try hard enough? Who is to say? What if he though of you as "jerk" for that, and somebody who does not deserve a nice "Thank you"?

Anyways, you have all the right to feel upset at whatever you want for whatever you want.
But the fact that you are upset does not necessarily make the other guy a "jerk."

--------
PS>
As an example from my own attitude adjustment struggles:

Do you think it would be right for me to think everybody who uses the words "kifu" or "moku" are jerks? I honestly dislike those words and each time they are used. I used to have the same attitude you do - I though of people who use them as pompous donkeys trying to show off just to make themselves feel more important and knowledgeable then they really are - basically, overcompensating for low intelligence and possibly bad acne.

Then I thought about it - for a long while - and I realized it was actually my problem, not theirs. And so it was up to me to adjust my attitude.

I am still working on that.
And I still hate the words, each time I see them used I cringe!
But I try not to think badly of the people who use them anymore.

Hope this helps.

_________________
- Bantari
______________________________________________
WARNING: This post might contain Opinions!!

Please point out the exact post in which I used the word jerk. That is not actually a word in my speaking vocabulary as I consider it to be a demeaning word which has no use in polite interaction.

_________________
Still officially AGA 5d but I play so irregularly these days that I am probably only 3d or 4d over the board (but hopefully still 5d in terms of knowledge, theory and the ability to contribute).

This is why I said OP (which means "Original Poster".)
Please observe that it is to his words that I object, not to yours.

To you, I only try to explain my position vs. what the OP (which means "Original Poster") said.

What's more - I agree with you, and I said so, that if you wish to ignore or avoid people who say "gg" - its your choice and I have absolutely no quarrel with that.

Not sure how I can make it any clearer, but if you PM me, I can try.

_________________
- Bantari
______________________________________________
WARNING: This post might contain Opinions!!

Admins would take an interest in that case.

Note that I have told a few (a very small few) users on KGS that, if they can't be polite at the end of the game, it's best if they don't say anything. That's a suboptimal solution, I know.

Definitely not British usage. Partly because we have neither the plant, nor that word for the drink (it's more commonly called "Buck's Fizz" here), and partly because our derogatory terms are much harsher.

_________________
Confucius in the Analects says "even playing go is better than eating chips in front of tv all day." -- kivi

You are right, and indeed my first post was a great example of me losing my temper and behaving like a jerk. That's how these things escalate. All the more reason to emphasize good manners in tense situations.


I don't expect being thanked for losing, I expect being thanked for providing my opponent with an opponent, and in the case that I lost, for having spent my time doing something with him or her that did not turn out the way I had hoped. By not thanking me, by acting against the social norm, my opponent is adding insult to injury, and I personally don't find that easy to ignore. You are again right that this does not necessarily make my opponent a jerk, but if we assume that they are aware of the social norm, speak English and nonetheless still decide that I ought not be thanked for my troubles, acting like a jerk seems like a plausible explanation, no?


Good for you! If I understand you correctly, you feel I ought to make an attitude adjustment myself. While this may be the case (it would certainly make such thankless situations more pleasant for me) But are the problems really just yours and mine and not theirs? Is there no cause to desire a correction of poor behavior? I have seen many a go discussion revolving around the misuse of non-English go terms, and I would like to think that some people have indeed recognized through such discussions that their usage of some terms was inappropriate. Just because someone misuses terms does not make them pompous - maybe they were simply repeating what they had been erroneously taught. Likewise, while my being offended is my problem, this does not preclude the hope that some people will try to behave in a way that appears less offensive. Is this exerting social pressure? Sure. And in the case of those who are not aware that wordless games can be perceived as offensive, I hope that they will start saying hi gg tx like the rest of us. That should make it easier for people like me to avoid those who actually want to behave like jerks.

_________________
Patience, grasshopper.

We I certainly heard it plenty when growing up in Britain. Maybe it is now used by the younger generation.

_________________
Still officially AGA 5d but I play so irregularly these days that I am probably only 3d or 4d over the board (but hopefully still 5d in terms of knowledge, theory and the ability to contribute).

Okay, I'll be pedantic. Buck's Fizz contains two parts juice to one part Champagne, versus the equal measures in a mimosa.

We learn something new every day. In my case, I learned there is a sensitive plant called a mimosa, and that it is a British derogatory term even if it is little known in contemporary Britain.

_________________
- Brady
Want to see videos of low-dan mistakes and what to learn from them? Brady's Blunders

A quick question for daal (and others).

How would you feel about a go server that required a positive comment at the end of a game? Maybe enforced by losing a few elo points if you didn't comply?

Would that reduce jerkism in your eyes or would it be a heavy-handed silly "feature" that offends more than it helps?

_________________
- Brady
Want to see videos of low-dan mistakes and what to learn from them? Brady's Blunders

I mentioned it a bit earlier, but I'm not bothered when people leave without saying anything.

Perhaps the reason I come to a different conclusion than daal is in the following:


Assuming that saying thanks is the social norm, and it's rude not to follow this social norm, then I agree with daal's argument.

But for me:
1.) It's not clear to me that saying anything at the end of the game is a social norm. There's nothing in the KGS interface that suggests this, and the only reason to assume users should do this is if you already have that expectation.

2.) I don't have that expectation. To me, the "game" is composed of the moves. The chat that people add is a nice extra, but is not a part of the game.

And perhaps the biggest:
3.) For something this trivial, I prefer to NOT have a social norm of saying thanks at the end of the game. If it's an expectation, then the sincerity becomes lost. The CGoban client might as well automatically output the text, "thanks" at the end of the game. When something is NOT the social norm, then I'm talking to a real person - not some social convention.

_________________
be immersed