Disdain for Internet Go

Mef · **#21**

jts wrote:

This is precisely why we tell beginners to chill out about rank.

you must be winning half your games, or else you would be 19k or 20k. And yet you feel, when you lose, that you got thrashed. Why? Because rank doesn't mean much when youre starting out. (heck, not sure how much it means after you've been playing for two years, either.)

Indeed...I mean at the 20k level all it might take is for one key concept to click and they see a sudden jump of several stones in strength within the same game*. Likewise it can take just one little slip up and it feels like you're three stones behind...in the end best to just hold tight and hang on for the ride (=

*Anecdotally, I think the vast majority of my progress from 20k-15k can be directly attributed to a stronger player reviewing one of my games and saying "Only leave a cutting point if you want your opponent to cut there". Of course as always your mileage may vary, offer void where prohibited, may not be valid in all states, some restrictions may apply.

jdl · **#22**

snorri wrote:

jdl wrote:

I'm currently one of those sandbaggers, but not intentionally. I had been playing on IGS for several months, and I didn't realize that my KGS ranking would disappear. Going from 6k to 30k has obviously made for some highly lopsided matches.

I don't understand why you'd go from 6k to 30k. If you don't play on KGS, eventually your rank becomes just "?" but that is not 30k. You just use automatch or manually request a game with a player that's near the rank you estimate you are at. Basically, the same that you would do with a new account.

It went to "?" for 1 game, which the automatcher treated as 30k. Then for the next half dozen games I was "28k?" and "27k?". Now it's spiked to "4k?". So I still have the question mark, but at least the automatch tool will be reflecting reality for now.

Mef · **#23**

jdl wrote:

snorri wrote:

jdl wrote:

I'm currently one of those sandbaggers, but not intentionally. I had been playing on IGS for several months, and I didn't realize that my KGS ranking would disappear. Going from 6k to 30k has obviously made for some highly lopsided matches.

I don't understand why you'd go from 6k to 30k. If you don't play on KGS, eventually your rank becomes just "?" but that is not 30k. You just use automatch or manually request a game with a player that's near the rank you estimate you are at. Basically, the same that you would do with a new account.

It went to "?" for 1 game, which the automatcher treated as 30k. Then for the next half dozen games I was "28k?" and "27k?". Now it's spiked to "4k?". So I still have the question mark, but at least the automatch tool will be reflecting reality for now.

If you are ? then you have to set your own rank for automatch. I think the first time you login it defaults to 26k though.

jdl · **#24**

Ah, I didn't know that I could set that. It doesn't appear to matter anymore though, and at least one player got a semi-decent review out of the deal.

BaghwanB · **#25**

The instant availability of online play is great, but I just haven't been able to get into it vs. F2F. Online makes me feel antsy and such compared to just pulling out a board and rattling some stones.

Between that and the fact that it is much harder for someone to walk away from a F2F game, I'll take in-person play any day of the week (esp. club Sundays).

Bruce "Online=Uptight" Young

DJLLAP · **#26**

I like playing in person better. At least when all the stones are the same size and actually fit on the board

I only get the chance to play in person games about 1-2 times a month though. I don't always make it to my club since I often play drums at my church.

DeFlow · **#27**

Playing in person is a lot more intense emotionally. Somehow I always feel bad for my opponent when he is on the losing side (strange habit, I know). In addition, I am really tense because there is more on the line. Some anonymous internet opponent does not demand my best, but if I play face to face, I want them to know my strength.

Wessik · **#28**

I experience no difference between playing on a board and playing online. Go is Go.

Disdain for Internet Go

Who is online