Spoilers:

_________________
I know nothing.

Played a fun FFA where I eliminated my opponents in alphabetical order and only made one unit which I announced at the start.
So hard to beat flying buildings and mutalisks and broodlords with only Zealots (and lots and lots of cannons) but managed it in the end.
It won't upload to replayfu - anyone know of anywhere else I can put it?

There's http://www.sc2replayed.com/ but imo it's a bit overkill for its purpose.

Btw sorry we couldn't get a game yesterday; I was playing a team game then. Hopefully your trial still has enough hours left.

Anyone going to MLG Dallas? I'm in Austin and I'll probably drive up for Sunday at least. Looks like passes to play are still not sold out, if they aren't sold out near the event I might get one (Gold player in MLG gogogo!)

Nice...I won't be able to make it, but Patrick might be there...maybe play a game of Go with him amidst the gamer crowd for Go publicity perhaps?

And oh, GSL S2 first ro64 games are starting in 4 hours at the time of this posting (2:00am PST)...notably, Terran legend Boxer, GSL S1 champ FruitDealer, and awesome cannon-rusher Inca will be playing . It's going to be epicccccccc.

Also, I started laddering on the 1v1 again feeling confident in my 8-finger play from all the custom games. I did surprisingly well and won 9/11 of my games against mostly 1200-1600 players, cheesing only about 2 of my games (Inca's cannon rush in a PvP, and a lot+cannon rush I learned from incontrol's game against machine in g1). I may end up being better with 8 fingers than 9 .

And oh, regarding my finger - I took out (carefully) about 30% of the scab, basically the areas I knew for sure wouldn't bleed if I were to remove. Unfortunately, there's this strange piece of what I think is tissue that was underneath the scab that's now awkwardly dangling out. I'm reallllllly tempted to just cut it off, but if I touch it it's super-sensitive and it just feels like bad aji for me to cut so for now it's just chilling there, dangling in all its glory. I look at my finger every day and am just awed by how the human body can heal by itself, I feel like Cell from DBZ.

So, I play protoss. Generally I play a 4 gate, with a push at about 8-9 minutes, transitioning into whatever weakness the push reveals (collosus vs mass marines, void rays vs turtles, etc etc).

Aside from the cannon rushes, (which I haven't ever bothered to practice) what is considered to be Cheese for protoss? Am I cheesing my way to victory with my 4 gate 10 unit splat rush?

Also, why did my game mix go from about 2/3 protoss to about 2/3 terran? I still don't see any zerg in bronze, even after the patch.

This tactic has allowed me to shoot up to third in my league. I'm trying to focus on my macro, and keep from being supply blocked. It's somewhat terrifying, taking my initial push out, because I'm often taking it out /right after/ warping the last 4 units in, leaving me preeeety much defenseless! I go for a mix of stalkers and zs, and try to work the group so that the z's charge up the ramp first.

Not surprisingly, people who wall off have a much better chance of blocking my initial rush, and often I lose in the longer games because I'm not so good at teching up, in spite of a significant lead in army strength. I have noticed that VRs are much less useful against anything but pure ground and pound mech builds. The one place I still aim for VRs early is in PvP against someone I know is dropping out cannons. A group of VRs with a few immortals can eat pylons for breakfast.

And, flying the VRs around to the back door and picking off probes is highly effective.

Had a fun game today where I lost to a guy who went pure battle cruiser. Pretty embarassing, since I started out by destroying his main, but terrans are slippery, and by the time I built my airforce, he had a /crapload/ of battle cruisers.

Really really frustrated that somehow I missed his second command center flying over my expansion on the way to the place it landed, but hey, it was an amusing game.

Is silver harder than bronze? Every once in a while, I'll find myself challenged in bronze league, but.. uh.. yeah, I've got a 50% win rate in spite of my occasional 'too tired to play' 10 game losing streak binge.

Lesson of the week:
Sometimes, you should just quit playing for the night. Even if you want to get 'just one win'.

A 4-gate off 1 base won't leave you room to be building probes and using all 4 gates to output units at the same time, so if you're 4-gating and efficiently using those 4 gates, then it can be considered an all-in because of the hit you're taking on your economy at the prospect of committing to what will hopefully be a successful push. Unless you did a ton of damage with a failed push (though then it wouldn't really be "failed"), you will be behind.

However, at the same time I wouldn't classify it as cheese because while it does take a hit to your economy, it doesn't ruin it as much as, say, a 6-pool. Unless you're at a top level, it's much easier to recover from a failed 4-gate rush than it is from a 6-pool, kind of like how it's much easier to recover from a 20 point deficit in the mid-game if you're a kyu player versus if you're a high dan.

And regarding Protoss cheese, the strategies that come to mind are:

1. Proxy 2/3 gate
2. Cannon rush
3. Korean 4-gate

I don't know how efficient it is. Often, I 4 gate, build up abotu 10-20 units, then toss them at the enemy. Since I'm kinda OCD about paying attention to fights (I uh.. get distracted easily by the 'we're under attack' sound effect.) I tend to have enough cash to build more workers and make my expansion and transition into immortals/collosi/voidrays.

Am I hurting myself by trying to straddle the road with a 4 gate? I often have as good or better economy compared to my opponent, even with my 4gate rush. Of course, my opponents generally.. well. They're bronze.

On my second day a guy laughed at me after rolling me up with M&M balls, informing me I sucked. He had over 500 games, and was in bronze, I really hope he's earned his promotion by now. It makes me wonder, am I really getting any better, or am I just playing against a whole lot of really new players? I look forward to playing in silver. Maybe then I'll at least be able to pretend I win for reasons other than the fact that my opponents are terrible.

My friend pointed out this 4-gate strategy to me, and I've liked it so far after one day. I was playing a Terran, and after my initial push discovered that he was going MMM. So I built Colossi, Carriers, and Stalkers. He went MMM, Viking, and Siege Tank. He comes and attacks my rich mineral expansion at the bottom of Blistering Sands with pretty much everything he's got, and everything gets wiped out except several of my Stalkers. So, I build a row of pylons near the back door of his base and pump out 16 Zealots, 16 Stalkers, a few Colossi (I think), and 3 Carriers and leveled his main and two expansions before he quit.

I've found that Stalkers, Colossi, and Carriers are a potent and potentially lethal combination. I went that in my last game against Terran. I apparently did more damage than I thought, since after he wiped out my first wave and I had to build more units because they all died, he didn't come in and attack my base. Instead he had to apparently expand and train more units and after 10 minutes he couldn't handle 8 Colossi, 9 Carriers, and several Stalkers.

_________________
My plan to become an SDK is here.

4 gate, if used properly, isn't meant to be an all-in game ender where you gg after he blocks your push. The point of a 4 gate is to buy time for an expansion and get an early contain to delay their expansion. It's certainly not economically possible to sustain a 4 gate push, by doing the initial 4 gate push and expanding at the same time, you recover the economy hit because you'll have tons more money coming in than your opponent. Once you're on 2 bases, having 4 warpgates isn't such a big deal.

And then it just goes into standard play from there since with a proper response your opponent will be able to take out your proxy pylon after not too long.

_________________

Again, when you make 4 gates, you have to cut probe production to be building units from all 4 gates...so if you're buying time to expand, it's better to do so with 3 gates instead (and 3 gate expand is common). If you're trying to expand after failing a 4-gate push, you won't have enough probes to transfer to the natural. The point of a 4-gate is not to contain or to buy time for an expo, it really is to try and end the game right there. Anything else is a matter of recovery.

I was practising my Zerg in some free games and happened to join a lobby with mouzMaNa. I checked his profile and he was 2000+ diamond. I decided to switch back to Protoss. It obviously wasn't him playing and I managed to win the game. Still, looks good in my match list

Arg. Soooo, so frustrating. Maintenance Tuesday, OK, Yeah, I get it, we'd like our servers not to melt down into flaming buggy balls of doom... but since they've tied battle.net to everything, now I can't even log on to the forums, or look up my character to see how many slots I fell on my ranking while I was at work.

Bleh.

Way to lock me out of everything game related.

Go Blizavision.

I've never had a problem keeping up with probe production during a 4 gate. I may not be a master at macro, but I've never had a problem like you described where I don't have enough probes to transfer. All you need is 1-2 sentries to keep your opponent contained in their base since you can just forcefield your ramp.

I don't know where you learned 4 gate from, but past bronze you're not supposed to use it as an early win.

Unless you're Korean 4 Gating.

_________________

4 gate isn't all-in. The strength of a 4 gate is really its first 2-3 rounds of production. After that, you are under no obligation to cut probes and can easily transition. It may not be the most economically oriented of builds, but it is very flexible and you can transition fairly well to a long game.

CSamurai: I don't recommend going voidray against fast cannon + expand build. The reason is because it turns what is a gamble on his part to a gamble on your part. You are relying on him not having adequate macro to defend voidrays, which is a iffy proposition. IMO, when the opponent goes cannons its pretty much a free win for me unless I screw up, and going voidrays is an unnecessary risk.

I've played 4 gate only a handful of times and found this to be the case.

_________________
My plan to become an SDK is here.

Then you're not macroing optimally. Show me 1 top-level replay where Protoss is warping in units from all 4 gates and pumping probes constantly and not converging to broke status off 1 base, just 1.

And you clearly haven't seen top-level tournament play; the majority of 4-gate play seen in such events are early wins or early losses. This is also consistent with what I've experienced in my own games. I'm not very good, but I'm certainly past bronze (1250 diamond with a broken finger) and the majority of my games where I 4-gate are, in fact, early wins...guess I must be "doing it wrong".


But in those first 2-3 rounds of production, you cut probe production so naturally if the push with the units from those first 2-3 rounds don't do enough damage, you'll usually be behind economically. This is all that I'm trying to say; you can't pump units out of 4 gates and still keep up probe production off 1 base simultaneously.

Here's a chat I just had with Time, a top 100 NA Protoss player; I've bolded parts where I felt he shared my stance on this topic:

You: hey patrick, can i ask a quick question?
Time: ya
Time: what's up?
You: cool; there's a little debate I've been having with someone regarding 4-gate
You: im just wondering from someone that's actually good on how "all-in" it is
You: and its potency to transition out of to expanding
Time: well
Time: usually it's pretty all-in and hard to transition out of
Time: it might be possible to like
Time: throw down a nexus and still go 4 gate
Time: but usually that just ends up making your attack too weak and your econ isn't strong either
You: right...so if a 4-gate push fails
You: transitioning is possible but your behind in economy right?
Time: ya
Time: I mean
Time: you can do a lot of economic damage
Time: and then expand
Time: and be even or ahead
Time: but if you don't do any damage to their econ you're gonna be behind
You: i see...
You: cause one guy says
You: he can keep up probe production
You: and produce units out of 4 gates which i dont believe to be true
Time: I mean
You: off 1 base
Time: I'm pretty sure some math geeks have done the calculation on tl and you can't support 4 gates with constant production unless it's 3 zealot/1 sentry every round and even then you're like totally broke
You: i see...
Time: which matchup are you talking about?
You: just in general
Time: like
Time: 4 gate PvT is totally all-in
Time: you can't reasonably expect to transition out of it
You: why is it different in PvT?
Time: well against zerg I feel like it's easier to do damage
Time: because if you force them to cut drones for a long time while they produce units to fend it off
Time: then you can have a stronger econ than them
Time: but against terran they can still make scvs while making other stuff
You: interesting
Time: also, if they were going for fast banshees
You: so in PvT, you'd consider it all-in, but in PvZ/PvP you wouldnt?
Time: and you don't kil them
Time: you can't have detection
Time: I don't understand PvP
You: hehe
Time: I have like
Time: 3 different all-in builds
Time: and sometimes I expand if I feel like it's a good idea
Time: but mostly it's just 1 base every game
You: interesting...
Time: if you want to go 4 gate
Time: and expand
Time: you can go like
Time: 1 gate
Time: nexus around 28 or something
Time: then add 3 more gateways
Time: it's pretty good in PvT and PvZ
You: yeah, i've been using this build that i saw HuK use a lot where i 1 gate FE to 5 gate
Time: and some people have claimed to get it to work in PvP
Time: ya he did it like every game at MLG
You: haha, yeah exactly
You: alright, well thanks for the tips
You: and nice carrier icon
Time: np
Time: thx

Day[9] did a whole daily (#169) on the 4 gate, showing some different 4 gate builds. He had one that was an "economy" 4 gate, but it wasn't what most people think of when they think 4 gate; it was basically late gas and using 4 gates for production while expanding, not the constant early pressure 4 gate is known for.

I feel naked without observers and I suck at rushing, so I never 4 gate myself.

_________________
KGS 4 kyu - Game Archive - Keyboard Otaku