Araban wrote:I just did Chinese counting on this to not worry about prisoners (after filling dame for both sides) and it comes out W+1.5, so it seems Kirby is right.
Japanese counting adds up to the same as is shown in this sgf.
(;GM[1]FF[4]SZ[19]GN[Move # idontcare - Prisoners: B=18, W=15]PC[http://lifein19x19.com/]AP[GoWiki:2009]DT[2010-06-27]C[Diagram from
http://lifein19x19.com/Move # idontcare - Prisoners: B=18, W=15]PL[W]AB[ga][ha][ia][ma][cb][db][gb][ib][jb][lb][nb][ob][pb][qb][sb][cc][ec][fc][gc][hc][lc][mc][rc][cd][md][nd][od][pd][qd][sd][ce][de][ge][he][je][qe][re][bf][df][ef][hf][jf][lf][nf][bg][cg][dg][gg][hg][lg][mg][ng][og][qg][bh][dh][gh][kh][lh][nh][ph][qh][di][hi][mi][ni][qi][ri][dj][kj][lj][nj][oj][qj][ck][fk][jk][kk][lk][pk][cl][dl][ll][pl][ql][bm][jm][km][lm][mm][om][pm][qm][an][bn][cn][jn][ln][mn][ao][co][eo][go][ko][cp][dp][ep][fp][np][qp][sp][dq][eq][gq][mq][qq][rq][sq][er][gr][nr][pr][qr][sr][gs][rs]AW[fa][ja][ka][la][eb][kb][rb][dc][ic][jc][kc][oc][pc][qc][dd][ed][fd][id][kd][ld][ee][fe][ke][le][me][pe][se][ff][gf][kf][mf][of][pf][qf][rf][eg][fg][ig][jg][kg][rg][sg][ch][eh][hh][ih][jh][sh][bi][ci][ei][fi][gi][ji][ki][li][pi][si][ej][jj][rj][ek][ik][nk][ok][qk][rk][el][il][jl][kl][nl][rl][cm][dm][fm][im][nm][rm][sm][dn][en][fn][in][nn][on][pn][qn][rn][bo][fo][jo][lo][mo][po][qo][so][ap][bp][gp][hp][jp][kp][pp][rp][bq][cq][fq][nq][oq][pq][cr][dr][fr][or][ds][es][fs][os][ps];W[ro]C[W1]MN[1];B[kn]C[B2]MN[2];W[sf]C[W3]MN[3];B[bl]C[B4]MN[4];W[hj]C[W5]MN[5];B[pj]C[B6]MN[6];W[sk]C[W7]MN[7];B[rh]C[B8]MN[8];W[sj]C[W9]MN[9];B[gd];W[hd];B[ie];W[if];B[jd];W[ne];B[oe];W[pg];B[ol];W[mk]
;B[mj];W[ml];B[qs];W[do];B[dk];W[fh];B[fb];W[gn];B[ea];W[ho]
;B[bj];W[ii];B[ai];W[mp];B[cj];W[mr];B[oi];W[lq];B[nc];W[ns]
;B[ra];W[no];B[am];W[op];B[al];W[fj];B[ak];W[gk];B[bk];W[fl]
;B[aj];W[fk];B[bi];W[em];B[ci];W[hq];B[ch];W[hr];B[ah];W[hs]
;B[ag];W[gq];B[af];W[gr];B[cf];W[gs];B[eb];W[go];B[fa];W[hn]
;B[da];W[gm];B[ca];W[hm];B[ae];W[gl];B[be];W[hl];B[ad];W[gj]
;B[bd];W[hk];B[ac];W[hi];B[bc];W[ij];B[pi];W[sl];B[rd];W[sn]
;B[qc];W[oo];B[pc];W[np];B[oc];W[lp];B[mb];W[io];B[na];W[ip]
;B[oa];W[iq];B[hb];W[jq];B[pa];W[kq];B[qa];W[mq];B[rb];W[nr]
;B[ab];W[aq];B[ba];W[ms])
On the board W is ahead by the 5 pts in the LL corner. Add 1/2 komi and deduct 1 prisoner out of the last moves and 3 prisoners from history and the grand total is 1.5 pts in favour of W.
I think I am so I think I am.
