KGS homophobia?

[gaius]

OK. So I like KGS. But I recently heard about something quite off-putting. Apparently, the admins barred the LGBT room from being public (it must be password-protected); also, it cannot even be called that way, it has to have a silly name like "Rainbow Friends". Right now, the room seems to have died because of too few games played. Yet, I wonder who felt the need for this strange policy, when virtually any other random social room is allowed...

[kirkmc]

Hmm, just wondering, are there social rooms for blacks, anti-abortion supporters, or members of any religious group?

Why does there need to be an "LGBT" room? Do these players need to be segregated?

[topazg]

I am a member of Rainbow Friends and I have a vague recollection of this, I think it was due to not creating a group that people would just flame for the sake of it. I agree I am not entirely happy with the precedent it sets, I don't think it was admin homophobia.

There have been some interesting episodes with the creator of the group also, but most of those seem resolved.

[amnal]

Whose idea was it to call it 'rainbow friends'?

Edit: Also, being in a room =/= segregated from other rooms.

[kirkmc]

Edit: Also, being in a room =/= segregated from other rooms.

It is, actually; it's self-segregation. Do you think there should be a black room? Not only is that segregation, but it suggests that others aren't wanted.

We're talking about go here; that there are rooms by language makes sense, but sexual preference? Should there therefore be rooms for every group that claims its difference?

[Stable]

Should there therefore be rooms for every group that claims its difference?

Yes, if they want one.

[CarlJung]

Sweet, who's starting the Grumpy Old Men room?

Oh nevermind, we already have the gd/L19 room.

[deja]

How about the Grumpy Old LGBT room. We're not all young and happy.

[amnal]

Edit: Also, being in a room =/= segregated from other rooms.

It is, actually; it's self-segregation. Do you think there should be a black room? Not only is that segregation, but it suggests that others aren't wanted.

We're talking about go here; that there are rooms by language makes sense, but sexual preference? Should there therefore be rooms for every group that claims its difference?

I suppose maybe it is technically segregation, but not in the way that I considered meaningful (unless the members ignore all the other rooms).

Given which, it's equally as damaging as the segregation arising from (say) the godiscussions/l19 rooms. Which don't seem problematic to me.

If people want to talk about stuff, they're welcome to. Sometimes if a significant number of them want to talk about the same thing, they might be told to join a different room and stop spamming (Which is why the English chat room and English game room are separate). If the different things to talk about centre around LGBT identity, having an LGBT room seems like a logical progression. I'd consider this sequence reasonable regardless of subject matter, the fact that it's LGBT doesn't seem important.

I wouldn't have read that 'others aren't wanted' any more than I'd read that those who don't want to chat may not enter the English chat room. I could be wrong, of course, maybe they would chase away the non-LGBT.

EDIT: But I still want to know who chose 'Rainbow Friends'

EDIT2: And yes, I don't care if people want to start a room called the black room, assuming people want to and that it is an entirely optional part of KGS (as any other room is). I don't think there *should* be one, but I don't care if someone wants to make one.

[mdobbins]

... Do you think there should be a black room?

Yes, for all the players who only want to play black!!

[mdobbins]

... But I still want to know who chose 'Rainbow Friends'

Does that have anything to do with playing with the green stones?

[wms]

H'mmm, I would need to know more about what happened I think. I certainly hope there is no homophobia going on there, but until you know the whole story it's impossible to say.

I do remember clearly when we had somebody complain about a user with name that made reference to him being gay and also to sex (can't remember the exact name any more). When I asked the guy to change his name, he called me a homophobe, until I pointed out that I had also asked "sexGoddess" (or some such) to change her name a few weeks earlier. Anyway, that seemed to calm him down - he was mad when he thought I was a homophobe, but I guess he didn't mind when he found out I was just a prude.

[Javaness]

OK. So I like KGS. But I recently heard about something quite off-putting. Apparently, the admins barred the LGBT room from being public (it must be password-protected); also, it cannot even be called that way, it has to have a silly name like "Rainbow Friends". Right now, the room seems to have died because of too few games played. Yet, I wonder who felt the need for this strange policy, when virtually any other random social room is allowed...

The reasoning for making it private was so that it couldn't be accessed by trouble making Homer-phobes, thus allowing the room without creating inevitable tedious work for admins. I, as an admin, ban users for homophobic remarks. Homophobia, like other types of abuse, is not tolerated on the server. It was purely a practical decision.

A while ago a user hijacked the room and locked everyone out of it, which probably contributed to the lack of games being played in it.

[daal]

... it's self-segregation. Do you think there should be a black room? Not only is that segregation, but it suggests that others aren't wanted.

I don't follow the logic. I sometimes go into the German room, though I'm not German, or to the Japanese room, though I'm not Japanese.

And you wouldn't be barred from going to a gay restaurant or bar either.

Rooms have particular themes so that people can get together with others who share that common interest. If you don't share that interest, you may not be banned, but you also might not be welcomed with open arms. Experiment: go into the French room and write something in English. See how long it takes till the word "Anglais" appears; that'll be someone complaining about your post.

[gaius]

The reasoning for making it private was so that it couldn't be accessed by trouble making Homer-phobes, thus allowing the room without creating inevitable tedious work for admins. I, as an admin, ban users for homophobic remarks. Homophobia, like other types of abuse, is not tolerated on the server. It was purely a practical decision.

A while ago a user hijacked the room and locked everyone out of it, which probably contributed to the lack of games being played in it.

That might make sense if there are too many problems there. My interest was sparked during a recent conversation in a bar with a lot of alcohol, so I missed out on a lot of the background story... Such a shame that it's necessary though.