Life In 19x19

Posted: **Tue Jul 06, 2010 7:12 pm**

FIREWORKS IN THE OLLEH KT CUP
Jul 05, 2010 08:46 pm | Mark Proctor

Although An Choyeong 9P became disagreeable during the scoring phase of last
Tuesday’s match in the Olleh KT Cup, requiring a tournament official to
mediate the dispute, he was ruled the winner, defeating Song Taekon 9P by
3.5 points in the game.

Does anyone have more information? The synopsis here makes it sounds as though the winner was in dispute, although if it's a ko-connection dispute like Go Seigen's, I have a difficult time imagining 4 whole points arising from one that a player feels he can indisputably avoid connecting.

Posted: **Tue Jul 06, 2010 7:21 pm**

I remember a similar story a year or two ago in Japan as well. Sometimes it's just whether it should be 2.5, 3.5, or 4.5 point win.

Posted: **Wed Jul 07, 2010 8:33 am**

That's why I like rulesets where disputes can be solved by simply playing it out(i.e. playing it out doesn't change the score)

Posted: **Wed Jul 07, 2010 9:11 am**

i try to look for any news on this dispute and didnt find any.
i reviewed the game and didnt find anything strange.
where did you hear that from???

Posted: **Wed Jul 07, 2010 7:23 pm**

Magicwand wrote:i try to look for any news on this dispute and didnt find any.
i reviewed the game and didnt find anything strange.
where did you hear that from???

It was in the weekly AGA E-Journal. This is the original source:
http://justplaygo.com/index.php/JPG/fireworks_in_the_olleh_kt/

And now that I realize the game record is there as well...

Looks like the final move by Black might have been at J10 instead, thus earning one point if by some crazy rules decision black unconditionally won the ko? In that case it wouldn't be game deciding, so it was just sort of a sensationalist article. I still find it weird though, and I'm looking for something else that could be the problem...

Posted: **Wed Jul 07, 2010 7:32 pm**

For everyone

Posted: **Thu Jul 08, 2010 4:55 am**

I think it was just a little bit of friction over the way stones were arranged during the count up. Nothing to do with rules. And I think An was just upset, not disagreeable.

People might like to know about the new olleh KT tournament. It's KT hello backwards, part of KT's new branding, meant to show innovation - though Jeonju natives apparently also claim the word in their local dialect (meaning something like "Good on yer, sport").
There's a 700 million won fund, 100 million to the winner. Players get 1 hour each plus 3x40 seconds, all games internetted. The prelim system is pretty labyrinthine - we are on Round 6 already - but I think it leads to a final KO of 16.

Posted: **Thu Jul 08, 2010 5:35 am**

John Fairbairn wrote:People might like to know about the new olleh KT tournament. It's KT hello backwards,

No it isn't ;-)

Life In 19x19

Scoring dispute between pros?

Scoring dispute between pros?

Re: Scoring dispute between pros?

Re: Scoring dispute between pros?

Re: Scoring dispute between pros?

Re: Scoring dispute between pros?

Re: Scoring dispute between pros?

Re: Scoring dispute between pros?

Re: Scoring dispute between pros?