Go-like game on a hex board that doesn't suck

[NickBentley]

*possibly* of interest: I figured out how to create a Go-like game on a hex board that doesn't suck, using a graph coloring trick. Here's a comparison between Go and it, focused on the basics of life. I'd love criticism.

[gowan]

How about the game Hex? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hex_(board_game)

[Bill Spight]

Interesting game!

[tj86430]

Here's a comparison between Go and it

I can't comment the game itself, but I must applaud the quality of that web page.

[NickBentley]

I can't comment the game itself, but I must applaud the quality of that web page.

Wow, thanks. No one has ever complimented me on that before, but I've spent a lot of time trying to make it usable and pleasant. That means a lot to me.

[NickBentley]

Interesting game!

Thanks kindly

[EdLee]

Hi Nick,

No one has ever complimented me on that before, but I've spent a lot of time trying to make it usable and pleasant.

Strange. Instantly noticeable. Like tj, I also appreciate all the work you put into the webpage design. Congrats.
( Browsing on a tiny iPhone5 screen, Safari. )

Good designs are rare to come by.

Won't complain about ugly Go clients, editors, etc.

Dunning-Kruger effect.

[NickBentley]

Won't complain about ugly Go clients, editors, etc.

Dunning-Kruger effect.

Haha

[Kirby]

Compared to go, the most interesting nuance of this game (to me) is the trade off between playing a single stone on a turn and two stones.

At first I didn't get the point of multiple colors per side, but then you pointed out how it takes more stones to capture a bloom.

When would you ever want to play just a single color on your turn?

[EdLee]

Hi Nick,

blooms_territory.PNG (48.42 KiB) Viewed 15630 times

Nitpicky suggestion:

• The Blooms territory arrow is clear and unambiguous ;
• The Go territory arrow is less... ( you elaborate in following text ) ;
• Perhaps an (almost) unconditionally alive shape is better than a locally dead shape... ? (I use a vertical shape consistent with your webpage flow)

$$
$$ -------
$$ | ? O .
$$ | ? O .
$$ | ? O .
$$ | ? O .
$$ | O O .
$$ | . . .
$$

Click Here To Show Diagram Code

[go]$$
$$ -------
$$ | ? O .
$$ | ? O .
$$ | ? O .
$$ | ? O .
$$ | O O .
$$ | . . .
$$[/go]

Or:

$$
$$ -------
$$ | C O .
$$ | C O .
$$ | C O .
$$ | C O .
$$ | O O .
$$ | . . .
$$

Click Here To Show Diagram Code

[go]$$
$$ -------
$$ | C O .
$$ | C O .
$$ | C O .
$$ | C O .
$$ | O O .
$$ | . . .
$$[/go]

[hyperpape]

How about the game Hex? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hex_(board_game)

I haven’t played Blooms, but I have played a moderate amount of hex (I am mediocre to bad). I think Hex is only go like in the loose sense that it’s more like go than like chess, and Blooms is probably more go-like.

[EdLee]

Hi Nick,

Another nitpicky suggestion:

grey_v_green.png (43.48 KiB) Viewed 15643 times

Re: Dress Meme and Laurel v. Yanny Meme.

On both an iPhone5 and Macbook Air, I see a slight green instead of the stated grey.
Perhaps 5 colors (board plus 4 stones) can be chosen to avoid meme-ness.
Example: beige board, ( red + Yellow ), ( + Green ).

[lightvector]

When would you ever want to play just a single color on your turn?

For the same reason that you would want to pass in Go. Maybe you've run out of useful things to do with that second color.

[Kirby]

When would you ever want to play just a single color on your turn?

For the same reason that you would want to pass in Go. Maybe you've run out of useful things to do with that second color.

Cool. I was wondering if there was a more general strategy that I was missing that might happen earlier in the game. In most cases, it seems useful to take the two moves.

[luigi]

Hi Nick,

Another nitpicky suggestion:

grey_v_green.png

Re: Dress Meme and Laurel v. Yanny Meme.

On both an iPhone5 and Macbook Air, I see a slight green instead of the stated grey.

Really? I see it quite clearly blue.